When fans think of Cy Young, they usually picture him as the dominant pitcher for the Cleveland Spiders or the Boston Americans (later Red Sox). However, his brief tenure in St. Louis from 1899 to 1900 is a lesser known chapter in his career.


To understand why Young landed in St. Louis, you have to look at the collapse of the Cleveland Spiders. In the late 19th century, team owners could own multiple franchises. The Robisons owned both the Cleveland Spiders and the St. Louis Perfectos. In 1899, they decided to stack their St. Louis team with all of Cleveland’s best players, including Cy Young.


Young, who had spent nearly a decade as Cleveland’s ace and was not thrilled about the forced relocation. He had built his reputation in Cleveland and likely felt a strong attachment to the team and city. Moreover, the St. Louis ownership situation was messy. The Perfectos (who became the Cardinals in 1900) were a mid-tier team, finishing fifth in the 12-team National League in 1899 with a 84-67 record.

Young continued to perform at an elite level. In 1899, he posted a 26-16 record with a 2.58 ERA and led the league in shutouts (5). His workload was enormous, he pitched 45 complete games and logged 336 innings. The following season in 1900, he went 19-19 with a 3.00 ERA, still ranking among the league’s best pitchers at that time.

In 1901, as Ban Johnson launched the American League, Young was personally recruited to join the Boston Americans. Seeing a fresh opportunity in a more stable organization, he left St. Louis behind. It turned out to be one of the best decisions of his career. He became the face of the new league, winning its first ERA title, and dominating for years.

Had the Perfectos/Cardinals been better managed, they might have retained Young and built a team around him. Instead, they lost one of the greatest pitchers of all time, while Boston reaped the rewards of his talent. St. Louis wouldn’t find lasting baseball success until the Cardinals emerged as a powerhouse in the 1920s.

Leave a Reply